Difference in quality and time


Instant Coffee
Occipital Skanect
Scan: 4 Min
Coloring <1 Min
Low quality mesh and texture


Instant Coffee
Agisoft Photoscan
Align: 3 Min
Build dense cloud: 2 H 39 Min
Building mesh: 8 Min
Removing unwanted geometry: 4 Min
Building texture: 3 Min
The software had problems with the glossy surface and the thin edges but the texture is of  high quality


House
Occipital Skanect
Scan: 3 Min
Coloring <1 Min
Low quality mesh and texture


House
Agisoft Photoscan
Align: 4 Min
Build dense cloud: 16 Min
Building mesh: 5 Min
Removing unwanted geometry: 2 Min
Building texture: 2 Min
Not too bad geometry and good texture quality


Green bust
Occipital Skanect
Scan: 2 Min
Coloring <1 Min
Low quality mesh and texture


Green bust
Autodesk 123D Catch
Upload: 4 Min
Create model: 52 Min
Removing unwanted geometry: 3 Min
Low quality mesh with decent texture


Green bust
Agisoft Photoscan
Align: # Min
Build dense cloud: 1 H 45 Min
Building mesh: 9 Min
Removing unwanted geometry: 3 Min
Building texture: <1 Min
High quality mesh and texture

Conclusion:
The Xbox Kinect camera + Occipital Skanect is the absolute fastest way to scan the objects. The resulting mesh and texture is of low quality and could possible work for props in cell phone games or for background objects in other games. Could also work as a base mesh to sculpt on. I will not be trying this anymore.

Autodesk 123D Catch gives better meshes and textures but the resulting mesh is always in two parts with their own texture. xNormal crashed every time I tried to bake the textures to a new copy of the mesh. The green bust had all it’s parts in one of the textures so I could use that one. It is simply not worth the hassle due to the random quality in results the software gives. Could possible work as a basemesh to sculpt on.

Agisoft Photoscan is the slowest but best software. The quality of the meshes and the textures is in it’s own league compared to the other two solutions.

I will try KSCAN3D with the Kinect, just to be sure that the bad results is from the camera itself and not the software used.

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *